ESG Risk Ratings (2024)

Knowing how exposed and how well your portfolio companies manage their material ESG issues is a critical part of making well-informed investment decisions.

That is why the world's leading investors rely on our ESG research and ratings for a consistent approach to evaluate financially material ESG issues that affect the long-term performance of their investments.

Covering more than 16,000 companies, Morningstar Sustainalytics has the widest coverage of analyst-based ESG Risk Ratings in the market. The newly expanded universe includes public and private companies, fixed-income issuers and listed Chinese companies and allows investors to support diversified investment strategies.

Learn more about why Sustainalytics’ ESG Research and Ratings are the industry standard.

Gain valuable insights on the potential economic and societal benefits of aligning with ESG standards, as well as the potential costs and disruptions.

Morningstar Sustainalytics Expands ESG Risk Ratings Coverage to Fixed Income, Private Equity, and China

Morningstar Sustainalytics' ESG Risk Ratings

Sustainalytics’ ESG Risk Ratings measure a company’s exposure to industry-specific material ESG risks and how well a company is managing those risks. This multi-dimensional way of measuring ESG risk combines the concepts of management and exposure to arrive at an absolute assessment of ESG risk. We identify five categories of ESG risk severity that could impact a company’s enterprise value

ESG Risk Ratings (4)

  • Key Benefits
  • Features

The Rigor and Comprehensiveness that the World’s Leading Investors Count On

ESG Risk Ratings (5)

Absolute Measure of ESG Risk

A sophisticated methodology for rating absolute ESG risk, while enabling best-in-class analysis. Company ratings are comparable across peers and subindustries and allow for easy aggregation at the portfolio level.

ESG Risk Ratings (6)

Extensive Coverage

The ESG Risk Ratings research universe includes more than 16,300 analyst-based ESG Risk Ratings, spanning public equity, fixed-income, and privately held companies. Additionally, the universe has enhanced coverage of Chinese companies listed in Shanghai and Shenzhen, which are predominant regional contributors in emerging market indices.

ESG Risk Ratings (7)

Integrated Corporate Governance Information

Fully integrated, comprehensive corporate governance research and ratings.

ESG Risk Ratings (8)

Transparent Methodology

Transparent methodology with multiple levels of data and qualitative insights to provide clients with custom ESG solutions.

ESG Risk Ratings (9)

Two-Dimensional Materiality Framework

Two-dimensional materiality framework measures a company’s exposure to industry-specific material risks and how well a company is managing those risks.

ESG Risk Ratings (10)

Three Central Building Blocks

Corporate governance, material ESG issues, and idiosyncratic issues (black swans) form the three central building blocks of our ESG research and ratings.

ESG Risk Ratings (11)

Five Risk Levels

The ESG Risk Ratings are categorized across five risk levels: negligible (0-10), low (10-20), medium (20-30), high (30-40) and severe (40+).

ESG Risk Ratings (12)

16,000+ Companies Covered

Sustainalytics' ESG Research and Ratings span more than 16,000 companies and encompass most major global indices.

ESG Risk Ratings (13)

20 Material ESG Issues

The ratings framework is supported by 20 material ESG issues that are underpinned by more than 300 indicators and 1,300 data points.

ESG Risk Ratings (14)

Flexible Accessibility

The ESG Risk Ratings are available through Global Access, Datafeeds and API as well as several third-party distribution platforms.

Human Insights Supported by AI Efficiency

ESG Risk Ratings (15)

DailyNewsMonitoring

AI-powered Digital Content Curation
Research analysts leverage smart technologies to enable them to monitor more than 60,000 media sources, and up to one million news articles daily.

ESG Risk Ratings (16)

Robust Annual Update Cycle

  • Company profiles updated annually with corporate reporting cycle
  • Alternative data sources, like regulatory filings on product recalls and NGO sources, augment self-reported corporate data
  • Analysis by a team of over 800 ESG research analysts supported by artificial intelligence powered descriptive and predictive analytic capabilities
  • Robust quality control mechanisms with peer reviews by senior analysts and company feedback mechanisms

About Our Framework

1. Total Exposure

We start with exposure, where exposure to each material ESG issue is initially determined at the subindustry level.

2. Manageable Risk

Next, we consider what part of the company’s risk can effectively be managed through ESG programs and policies.

3. Unmanageable Risk

For some companies, a portion of its risk may be considered unmanageable. For example, an oil company is not able to fully eliminate all its risks related to carbon emissions so that is factored out of the calculation.

4. Managed Risk

For the portion of risk that is manageable, a company’s performance is reflected by its policies, programs, practices and quantitative performance measures.

5. Management Gap

The management gap reflects the risk that is not managed. In addition, controversies have a discounting effect on the company’s management score as they demonstrate shortcomings in the company’s programs and policies.

6. Unmanaged Risk

Overall a company’s ESG Risk Rating is calculated by adding the amount of unmanaged risk for each material ESG issue.

Investor Use Cases

ESG Risk Ratings (24)

ESG Integration

Multi-dimensional ESG risk scores can be incorporated into equity or bond valuation models and aggregated at the portfolio-level.

ESG Risk Ratings (25)

Best-in-Class Investment Analysis

Comparable company scores support flexible applications for best-in-class analysis, including subindustry, sector or regional approaches.

ESG Risk Ratings (26)

Screening and Benchmarking

Overall Risk Ratings and material ESG issue scores support risk-based ESG screens and enable robust benchmarking across and within sectors and subindustries.

ESG Risk Ratings (27)

Thematic Investing

Scores on material ESG issues support thematic investment themes and provide meaningful new input for fund and index creation.

ESG Risk Ratings (28)

Engagement and Voting

Material ESG issue framework effectively supports engagement with companies on priority ESG issues and informs voting decisions on E&S shareholder resolutions.

ESG Risk Ratings (29)

Reporting & Promotion

Communicate sustainability performance and commitment through ESG reporting and leverage theMorningstar Sustainability RatingTM for funds for marketing purposes.

Report Insights

1. Company Rating

Company ratings are categorized across five risk levels: negligible, low, medium, high, and severe and represented by our ESG Globes icons.

ESG Risk Ratings (30)

2. Company Risk

A company’s risk is measured against its industry peers and against the global universe.

ESG Risk Ratings (31)

3. Rich Company Analysis

Qualitative analysis, underpinned by analyst insights and quantitative data, describes the reasons why a company is exposed to specific material ESG issues and explains how well a company is managing these issues.

ESG Risk Ratings (32)

4. Material ESG Issues

Material ESG Issues (MEIs) are identified and brought into focus.

ESG Risk Ratings (33)

5. Company Events

Transparency into company events that may impact a company’s operations, stakeholders or the environment.

ESG Risk Ratings (34)

6. ESG Risk Decomposition

The magnitude to which a company is exposed to ESG risk and how well the company is managing that risk is measured and explained.

ESG Risk Ratings (35)

ESG Risk Ratings (36)ESG Risk Ratings (37)ESG Risk Ratings (38)ESG Risk Ratings (39)ESG Risk Ratings (40)ESG Risk Ratings (41)

Why Sustainalytics?

ESG Risk Ratings (42)

A Single Market Standard

Consistent approach to ESG assessments across the investment spectrum.

ESG Risk Ratings (43)

Award-Winning Research and Data

Firm recognized as Best ESG Research and Data Provider by Environmental Finance and Investment Week.

ESG Risk Ratings (44)

End-to-End ESG Solutions

ESG products and services that serve the entire investment value chain.

ESG Risk Ratings (45)

30 Years of ESG Expertise

800+ ESG research analysts across our global offices.

ESG Risk Ratings (46)

A Leading SPO Provider

As recognized by Environmental Finance and the Climate Bonds Initiative.

  • Related Products
  • Related Indexes

ESG Risk Ratings (47)

Climate Solutions

Identify and manage investment risks and opportunities with climate research, ratings and data for investors.

Learn More

ESG Risk Ratings (48)

Material Risk Engagement

Engage on the most material ESG risks identified by the ESG Risk Ratings.

Learn More

ESG Risk Ratings (49)

Impact Solutions

Measure, manage and report on the social and environmental impact of your portfolio.

Learn More

Morningstar® Global Market SustainabilitySM Index Family

Best-in-class equity index that features reduced ESG risk profile​ with low to moderate tracking error.

Morningstar® Sustainability Dividend Yield FocusSM Index Family

High Income generating equity investments focused on total returns with reduced ESG Risk.

Morningstar® Global Corporate Bond Sustainability IndexesSM

Diversified corporate bond portfolio that avoids bonds with high ESG risk relative to their sector peers.

Morningstar® Sustainability Moat IndexesSM

Exposure to companies that have distinct competitive advantages as well as low ESG Risk.

Related Insights and Resources

ESG Risk Ratings (50)

Navigating the EU Regulation on Deforestation-Free Products: 5 Key EUDR Questions Answered About Company Readiness and Investor Risk

The EUDR comes into effect in December 2024, marking an important step in tackling deforestation. In this article, we answer five key questions who the EUDR applies to, how companies are meeting the requirements, and the risks non-compliance poses to both companies and investors

Read More

Article

ESG Risk Ratings (51)

Child Labor in Cocoa Supply Chains: Unveiling the Layers of Human Rights Challenges

Child labor remains a persistent issue in the cocoa supply chain. So can major food brands do to stop it? Discover the steps companies can take to address the issue and ways investors can engage with companies to mitigate it.

Read More

Article

ESG Risk Ratings (52)

The State of ESG Risk Across Industries: Three Key Takeaways From Our Annual Industry Reports

Morningstar Sustainalytics’ Annual ESG Risk Ratings Industry Reports are now available. Discover the cross-industry insights that emerge from this year’s reports and the research behind them.

Read More

Article

ESG Risk Ratings (53)

The Raw Materials Crunch: Industry Risks Due to Physical Scarcity, Supply Concentration and Intense Demand

As demand for critical raw materials increases, due in part to the low-carbon transition, industries reliant on those materials face growing risks. In this article, discover what’s driving those risks.

Read More

Article

Copyright © 2023 Sustainalytics. All Rights Reserved.

By accessing this website you confirm that as of December 1st, 2023, the ESG-related information, methodologies, tools, ratings, data and opinions contained or reflected herein are not directed to or intended for use or distribution to India-based clients or users and their distribution to Indian resident individuals or entities is not permitted, and Morningstar/Sustainalytics accepts no responsibility or liability whatsoever for the actions of third parties in this respect.

ESG Risk Ratings (2024)

FAQs

What is a good ESG risk score? ›

Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) scores are an essential tool for investors to assess a company's sustainability and ethical performance. These scores typically range from 0 to 100, with a score of less than 50 considered relatively poor and more than 70 considered good.

How reliable are ESG ratings? ›

The ESG score is not a reliable predictor of market success on its own, and there are numerous concerns with the existing lack of rules and transparency surrounding the criteria utilized for grading. Recently, however, agencies worldwide have sought to address these concerns.

What is the flaw in ESG ratings? ›

Lack of quality data is traditionally identified as the main barrier to the objectivity of ESG ratings. Agencies tend to rely on self-disclosures from the rated companies or obtain data from third-party sources that is no more reliable than what firms provide themselves.

How do you quantify ESG risk? ›

Quantifying ESG risk involves understanding relevant ESG factors for an entity, understanding each factor's importance for the entity, assigning weights based on the importance, and then scoring an entity's initiatives and measures to mitigate the ESG risk.

What is Tesla's ESG score? ›

Industry Comparison
CompanyESG Risk RatingIndustry Rank
Porsche AG17.1 Low16 out of 90
Mercedes-Benz Group AG18 Low17 out of 90
Tesla, Inc.24.7 Medium43 out of 90
BYD Co., Ltd.26.1 Medium51 out of 90
1 more row
May 23, 2024

Is it good to have a low ESG score? ›

Is a low ESG score good? A low ESG score is relatively poor. Though the scoring and rating scales vary between agencies, a score below 50 is bad, while a score above 70 is considered strong.

What is Disney's ESG score? ›

-7.01
High ratingB (70.9)
Low ratingC (56.4)
Average ratingB (65.6)
Change in rating-7.01
1 more row

What is Apple's ESG score? ›

ESG Risk Score for Peers
NameTotal ESG Risk scoreG
FUJIF FUJIFILM HOLDINGS CORPORATION177
ANET Arista Networks, Inc.177
AAPL Apple Inc.179
GLW Corning Incorporated166
1 more row

What are the drawbacks of ESG ratings? ›

Though ESG ratings have faced scrutiny for their perceived lack of precision, inconsistency, and potential role in promoting greenwashing, experts are encouraging the refinement and correction of these drawbacks instead of abandoning the entire ESG rating system.

How to do an ESG risk assessment? ›

5 steps to executing a materiality assessment for ESG risk
  1. First, create a steering committee. ...
  2. Identify specific stakeholders. ...
  3. Compile a list of material issues. ...
  4. Meet with individual stakeholders. ...
  5. Analyze material issues & create strategy.
Feb 21, 2023

How to calculate ESG score? ›

An ESG Scoring Example

If a manufacturing company scores 80 out of 100 on environmental factors, 70 on social factors, and 90 on governance factors, the final ESG score would be calculated as follows: (0.5 * 80) + (0.3 * 70) + (0.2 * 90) = 76.

What is my personal ESG score? ›

The personal ESG score assesses an individual based on three main factors: their environmental, social, and governance impacts. Many companies now believe that only individuals who prioritise corporate sustainability can be trusted with high-responsibility tasks.

What is an average ESG score? ›

Average – Average ESG scores are between 50-59. The company likely isn't implementing most ESG best practices, isn't actively working toward ESG goals, and has adverse environmental, social, or governance effects. Poor – A score of 50 or less is considered a poor ESG score.

What is a normal ESG level? ›

Normal ECG values for waves and intervals are as follows: RR interval: 0.6-1.2 seconds. P wave: 80 milliseconds. PR interval: 120-200 milliseconds.

What is a good ESG report? ›

A good report provides a comprehensive view of material ESG issues specific to your industry and operations. By analysing these insights, you can identify the most relevant and impactful issues for your organisation.

Who has best ESG score? ›

Top 100 ESG Companies
RankCompanyESG Score
1ASML Holdings N.V.73.13
2Check Point Software Technologies72.64
3Hermes International SCA71.71
4Linde71.26
39 more rows

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 5721

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.